abstract classes in python: Enforcing type

2024/10/12 1:29:36

My question is related to this question Is enforcing an abstract method implementation unpythonic? . I am using abstract classes in python but I realize that there is nothing that stops the user from implementing a function that takes an argument that is totally different from what was intended for the base class. Therefore, I may have to check the type of the argument. Isn't that unpythonic?

How do people use abstract classes in python?

Answer

Short answer: yes it is unpythonic. It might still make sense to have an abstract base class to check your implementations for completeness. But the pythonic way to do it is mostly just duck-typing, i.e. assume that the object you work with satisfies the specification you expect. Just state these expectations explicitly in the documentation.

Actually you typically would not do a lot of these safety checks. Even if you would check types, one might still be able to fake that at runtime. It also allows users of your code to be more flexible as to what kind of objects they pass to your code. Having to implement an ABC every single time clutters their code a lot.

https://en.xdnf.cn/q/118256.html

Related Q&A

Convert image array to original svs format

Im trying to apply a foreground extraction to a SVS image (Whole Slide Image) usign OpenSlide library.First, I converted my image to an array to work on my foreground extraction:image = np.asarray(oslI…

Printing bytestring via variable

I have the following Unicode text stored in variable:myvariable = Gen\xe8veWhat I want to do is to print myvariable and show this:GenveI tried this but failed:print myvariable.decode(utf-8)Whats the ri…

Loop and arrays of strings in python

I have the following data set:column1HL111 PG3939HL11 HL339PG RC--HL--PGI am attempting to write a function that does the following:Loop through each row of column1 Pull only the alphabet and put into…

2 Dendrograms + Heatmap from condensed correlationmatrix with scipy

I try to create something like this: plotting results of hierarchical clustering ontop of a matrix of data in pythonUnfortunatelly when I try to execute the code, I get the following warnings:Warning (…

Iterator example from Dive Into Python 3

Im learning Python as my 1st language from http://www.diveintopython3.net/. On Chp 7, http://www.diveintopython3.net/iterators.html, there is an example of how to use an iterator.import redef build_mat…

Getting a 500 Internal Server Error using render_template and Flask [duplicate]

This question already has answers here:How to debug a Flask app(13 answers)Comments not working in jinja2(2 answers)Closed 5 years ago.I am trying to use Flask to render an HTML template. I had it work…

Bokeh use of Column Data Source and Box_Select

Im lost as to how to set up a Column Data Source so that I can select points from one graph and have the corresponding points highlighted in another graph. I am trying to learn more about how this work…

How Does a Pyqtgraph Export for Three Subplots Look Like?

Using PyQtGraph, I would like to generate three sub plots in one chart and export this chart to a file.As I will repeat this a lot of times, it is quite performance sensitive. Therefore I do not need t…

Use class variables as instance vars?

What I would like to do there is declaring class variables, but actually use them as vars of the instance. I have a class Field and a class Thing, like this:class Field(object):def __set__(self, instan…

Get amount from django-paypal

I am using django-paypal to receive payment. I am currently paying as well as receiving payment using sandbox accounts. The payment procedure seems to be working fine. My problem is once I get back the…